top of page

1+1: Analysis vs panoramic view + DisruptHR

Writer: Josh Wymore
Josh Wymore
Oct 13
3 min read

Here's one leadership idea and one resource I’ve found beneficial in the past two weeks:


1 idea: Analysis vs panoramic view + DisruptHR

Imagine you're trying to make a monumental decision like whether to propose to your girlfriend or not. You like her, but you're just not sure she’s the one. How should you make your choice? Consider these two options:


Option One: Analyze her. Study how she talks to other men to calculate the odds that she will cheat on you. Scrutinize her laugh to determine if it will annoy you in 20 years. Conduct a post-mortem on your dates. It was a good date…but was it a great date? Could it have been better? If so, how? Would you have had a better time with someone else?


Option Two: Relax and enjoy time with her. Get to know what makes her laugh, what makes her cry, and what annoys her. Ask your friends for their perceptions of her. Notice how you feel when you're with her and apart from her. Imagine what your life would look like together.


Which approach do you think would be most effective?


I can tell you from first-hand experience that Option One stinks worse than a pair of three-day-old socks. During the first three months that I was dating Emily, I analyzed everything. I conducted post-mortems on our dates, and in every one, I’d convince myself that because the date wasn’t perfect, we should break up. Every time I went searching for flaws, I found them, giving me more reasons to break things off. Option One made both of us miserable and got me no closer to a confident answer.


Analysis is a powerful tool, but like anything, it has its limitations. Viewing the world through a magnifying glass helps us understand the details but can cause us to miss out on the bigger picture. If I asked you to tell me about your best friends, you could list out their height and weight and hair color--but these facts wouldn't give me a sense of who they are as people or why you enjoy them. Dissecting a living thing kills that thing. To understand your dynamic, I would need more than analysis: I would need to see the panoramic whole. 


Why does this distinction between analysis and the panoramic view matter? Because when it comes to leadership and decision-making, our Western culture has a strong bias toward analysis. We love data that can be articulated clearly in numbers but discount intuitions, impressions, and images as too subjective. Words and numbers give us a sense of safety because they can be dissected and analyzed.


But while this cold and calculated approach to decision-making feels safe, it actually excises the parts of us that make us most human: our emotions, values, dreams, and gut feelings. One of the main reasons leaders feel so conflicted with their decisions is that they have lost touch with this part of themselves. As a result, they feel inauthentic, unsure of themselves, and joyless.


Despite my over-analyzing tendencies, Emily stuck around and convinced me to chill out. I did, opting for the more holistic approach of Option Two. Once I stopped dissecting our relationship and hunting for flaws, I found so much to love. I noticed that I really enjoyed being with her. I could see how our values aligned and how we made each other better. I enjoyed talking to her, and I missed her when we were apart. I realized I wanted to marry her.


The choice wasn’t illogical—it was more than logical. Analysis alone never could have revealed the living, breathing chemistry we had or how we were better together than alone. Integrating the panoramic and the detailed view helped me make a holistic (and terrific!) decision that I'm still benefiting from 15 years later. 


***


  • Which big decisions are you trying to make right now?

  • What do your values, emotions, and intuitions have to say about this decision?

  • How would you feel differently if you gave these intangible factors equal weight in the process?


1 resource: DisruptHR

On October 22nd, I’ll be sharing a five-minute preview of my new book at DisruptHR—a one-night HR conference that’s a bit like a TED talk on steroids. If you are in the Fort Wayne area and are interested, you can register here.



Cover of James Clear's book Atomic Habits

Comments


bottom of page