top of page

1+1: Organizational health beats talent + The organizational health playbook

Writer: Josh Wymore
Josh Wymore
Oct 27
3 min read

Here's one leadership idea and one resource I’ve found beneficial in the past two weeks:


1 idea: Organizational health beats talent 

Imagine that it’s the final game of the year for your favorite sport. This match pits the defending champs against the Cinderella story of the season—an undersized and outmatched team who has miraculously hung on to win all season long. The odds are heavily stacked against them, and as much as you hope they'll win, the smart money is on the champs.


But the night before the big game, ESPN breaks a huge story: the entire starting lineup for the defending champs is bed-ridden with pneumonia. A few players are even fighting for their lives. But despite this obvious setback, the coach confidently declares that he’s making no changes to the starting lineup. He predicts that these sick players will play and win tomorrow’s game.


At the watercooler the next day, the question is: who's your pick to win the game? The sick but talented team, or the healthy but less flashy one?


Barring a miraculous recovery (like Michael Jordan’s “flu” game in 1997), the choice is obvious. In a battle between health and talent, health wins most of the time.


Yet as clear-cut as that choice might be in a sports scenario, it’s astounding how often we choose talent over health in business:


  • We hire a driven achiever whose personal life is completely out of balance. They produce instant results, then slowly fall apart in front of our eyes.

  • We promote the star individual contributor who hits all the goals but lacks emotional intelligence or boundaries. They proceed to run their team into the ground, driving away your best performers and demoralizing the rest.

  • We delegate to the overworked high-performer rather than developing the younger talent behind them—further stressing out this senior leader and discouraging the junior ones.


Dazzled by the promise of instant and spectacular results, we make short-term decisions that undermine our long-term success. We choose talent instead of overall health, and our celebrations are short-lived.


It’s not that talent doesn’t matter—it’s just that health matters more. Without health as a foundation, we can’t maximize our talent.


  • A talented leader who’s exhausted will struggle to think clearly and make sound decisions.

  • A talented team that lacks trust won’t listen well or be vulnerable with one another. As a result, they will fail to tap into the individual strengths and unique perspectives of their team members, and they will perform worse than less-talented groups.

  • A talented organization that lacks clarity and unity will work against itself. As they waste time on gossip, workarounds, and infighting, they lose to less-talented competitors.


Talent may beat health once or twice, but over the long haul, victory goes to the healthy. Had Tom Brady stayed in the NFL for the typical quarterback tenure, his stats wouldn’t even rank him as one of the top 50 QBs all time. But instead, he stayed healthy enough to play 23 years—longer than all but five other NFL players ever. Instead of disappearing from our memories after five years, he retired as the undisputed GOAT.


If you just want to post big results this year, choose talent. But if you want to build an enduring legacy, start with health.


***


  • What does “health” look like in my context?

  • Where am I tempted to prioritize talent over health?

  • What would investing in my organization’s health look like in the next six weeks?


1 resource: The organizational health playbook

If you care about organizational health, there’s no better book than Patrick Lencioni’s The Advantage. And if you’re looking for someone to help your organization implement these health practices, let’s talk. I’d love to help you get healthier so you can maximize your talent and results.



Cover of James Clear's book Atomic Habits

Comments


bottom of page